Go to the id21 home page   ID21 - communicating development research
Global Issues
 
Search the whole id21 database
 

Help page and other search methods
    id21 Global Issues
  Population change
  Food security
  Climate change
  Gender
  Poverty
  Human rights
  Global economy
  Governance
  Aid
  Conflict
and emergencies
  Tourism
 
    id21 Health
 
    id21 Education
 
    id21 Urban Development
 
    id21 Natural Resources
 
    id21 Rural Development
 
    id21 Home page
 
    Gender and Violence in African Schools
 
    id21 Publications
 
    id21 Viewpoints
 
    About id21
 
    Links
 
    Contact id21
 
    id21News
 
    id21 Insights
 
    id21 Media
 
     
Closing down mines: benefits of partnership in Indonesia

Mining companies are recognising the need to manage social issues resulting from mining activities and to maximise development benefits. A case study from the Indonesian island of East Kalimantan suggests how to implement tri-sector partnerships (between companies, communities and government) when mines become uneconomic and have to close.

A report commissioned by the World Bank's Business Partners for Development programme examines Kelian Equatorial Mining. KEM operates one of the world’s largest open-cut gold mines in a remote area of the island of East Kalimantan. The researcher shows how even in a conflict-prone context it is possible to get all relevant stakeholders to reach consensus and to collectively own unpleasant decisions and actions.

KEM, which is 90 percent owned by Rio Tinto plc, was established under the repressive Suharto regime when benefits from such large enterprises benefited central government with little regard for local needs. The mine was scheduled to close in 2004. Local perceptions that communities have not benefited sufficiently from its operations came into the open after the collapse of the Suharto regime in 1998 with demands for local government and communities to play a greater role in decision-making.

From 1999 to 2000, as mine-workers and local people became aware of the imminence of closure, conflict between the two sides led to a 40 day strike. Local people:

  • felt they had received insufficient or no compensation for land used by the mine and for access roads
  • accused KEM staff of sexual misconduct and human rights abuses
  • alleged that KEM had broken promises regarding community development projects
  • thought that retrenchment packages offered by KEM were inadequate.

These tensions were problematic because the successful management of issues related to the closure – loss of local livelihoods, the safety of dams made from waste rocks, water quality and other environmental concerns – required the involvement of local communities and the government. For KEM a successful closure process in accordance with local law and international environmental standards was vital for continued operations elsewhere in Indonesia and for Rio Tinto’s global reputation.

The priority was to establish an agreed grievance-resolution process. A Mine Closure Steering Committee (MCSC) was set up which led to local, provincial and national officials sitting down with the company and local people. The MCSC decided to establish separate working groups to look at dams, the environment, site uses and assets and community development and district planning.

Key factors in the subsequent success of the tri-sector partnership are due to:

  • KEM’s commitment to a consensus-based decision-making process
  • accountability and transparency: agreement on a list of criteria to devise and decide upon options provided an objective framework for decision-making
  • the communication strategy of the MCSC Secretariat, efficient recording of meetings and wide dissemination of decisions taken
  • clear separation of the political and technical aspects of decision-making and use of effective third-party facilitation.

Thanks to the work of the MCSC most outstanding closure, employment, asset handover and environmental issues have been settled. In addition, KEM will construct and finance a dormitory and model farm alongside a school, provide agriculture extension officers, donate tractors and offer management training for small enterprises. As an important by-product, community institutions and government officials have learnt to work together.

In terms of public-sector governance the partnership has provided a globally replicable template for mine closure by establishing procedural standards for the management of a wide range of labour, environmental, social and developmental issues. It has provided a model for participatory decision-making and accountable governance at a time of political and institutional changes across Indonesia.

 

Source(s):
‘Kelian Equatorial Mining, Indonesia: mine closure’ by Ralph Hamann, in ‘Putting partnerships to work: strategic alliances for development between government, the private sector and civil society’, Greenleaf Publishing, edited by Michael Warner and Rory Sullivan, 2004
Kelian gold/silver mine, Indonesia Full document.

Funded by: The World Bank

id21 Research Highlight: 8 September 2005

Further Information:
Ralph Hamann
Research Manager
African Institute of Corporate Citizenship
9 St David's Place, Parktown, Johannesburg
PO Box 37357, Birnam Park 2015
South Africa

Tel: +27 (0)11 643 6604
Fax: +27 (0)11 643 6918
Contact the contributor: ralph@aiccafrica.org

African Institute of Corporate Citizenship, South Africa

Business Partners for Development / Natural Resources Cluster
Overseas Development Institute
111 Westminster Bridge Road
London SE1 7JD
UK

Contact the contributor: info@bpd-naturalresources.org

Business Partners for Development

Other related links:
'Victims of progress: resettling people displaced by development'

'Responding to displacement: Balancing needs and rights'

The Mineral Policy Insitute is keeping an eye on mining

MPI provides the latest on Indonesia's mining

Views expressed on these pages are not necessarily those of DFID, IDS, id21 or other contributing institutions. Unless stated otherwise articles may be copied or quoted without restriction, provided id21 and originating author(s) and institution(s) are acknowledged.

Copyright © 2007 id21. All rights reserved.

Week beginning Monday 24th November 2008
FREE Information Delivery services from id21:
Get updates by email: id21 news
Insights: research digests
Contact id21

 

 

Go to the African Institute of Corporate Citizenship, South Africa site.

 

 

Go to the Business Partners for Development site.