Go to the ID21 home page

Insights
id21 logo ID21 Home
id21 logo Insights
id21 logo Issue #29
Empty desks, empty futures The curse of classroom gender gaps
The culture trap: Reasons why girls drop out in Ghana
-
Getting gender onto the policy agenda
Caribbean enigma: boys achieving badly
Girls, schools and limits to change
-
Does poverty cause gender inequality in schooling?
Gender gap in India's schools
Sites for Sore Eyes
- - -

March 1999 Insights Issue #29

Back to Insights #29

The culture trap

Reasons why girls drop out in Ghana

Do we always acknowledge the cultural framework within which educational development occurs? And are we alert to the interplay between different domains (the home, the school, the economy) where policymakers and policy researchers focus their attention and seek to intervene for the better? Not nearly enough, argues the report on a study that set out to explore reasons why girls drop out of primary school in Ghana. The realities of school and home life matter, it says, no less than educational inputs and outputs.

The study took place in two contrasting areas of Ghana, setting out in 1994 with aims linked to those of the UN World Decade of Cultural Development (1988-1997). A team composed mostly of Ghanaian researchers used culturally sensitive research methods (generally in the form of life history interviews) to probe issues in the home, the school and the economy that might affect school access and drop-outs. An attempt was then made to compare experiences of girls in and out of regular schooling, with those of female schoolteachers who had 'succeeded' in their educational life journeys, even while contending with past eras of economic hardship.

Donors and government agencies had recently made efforts to review and improve educational provision for girls. The study also sought, therefore, to refer the impact of these and other policy interventions to the actual experiences of Ghana's women and girls. A key finding of the study in relation to the home domain was that socialisation of the child in her home compound affects her (and her teachers') attitude to knowledge. Furthermore:

  • Home life is shaped by issues of kinship and descent and the practice of fostering
  • Cultural values of elders govern quantity and quality of schooling girls get
  • Fathers' support for daughters'schooling is vital, especially in the south of Ghana
  • Traditional views on the role of women in society colour girls' school experiences
  • Low expectations of the economic value of schooling for girls limits their choices.

In the economic domain, on a macro (national or international) scale, the introduction of structural adjustment policies has placed a growing burden of user fees for health and education services on needy people living at the margins of society and the formal economy. Worst affected are poor rural families in the north of Ghana that rely on crops that command no cash or export value. At the micro (local and household) level, the survey showed girls were often sole breadwinners in many extended families and thus had to contrive coping strategies to juggle conflicting school and work demands.

Many children regard the domain of the school as one where little of value is done or learned. Looking into the culture of the classroom, researchers came across attitudes to knowledge, teaching methods and language policies that tended only to hamper improvement. The life of teachers is hard and their status in the community low. For the child, positive experiences such as being well taught in basic skills of literacy and numeracy, having able women teachers to look up to as role models and being spared from unjust corporal punishment are too often lacking from her school life. Policy lessons arising from the study hinge on:

  • Understanding the whole life of the child as she moves between home and school
  • Focusing not only on inputs and outputs of the educational systems but also on the day-to-day experiences of children within schools
  • Acknowledging that dropping out is a process that places in an 'at risk' situation a child who, with appropriate support, early warning and safety-net measures, could be seated at her desk and looking forward to a better future
AMINA (NOT HER REAL NAME) WAS AGED 14 and doing averagely well in class 6 at her local primary school in Pomadze. Then the school asked her to pay an 800 cedis (worth £0.5 or US$ 0.8 in 1994) fee to cover the end-of-term exams that take children into the remaining three years of junior secondary schooling. Unable to raise the fee, she remained at home during the summer term. Her parents having split up, she was living with elderly grandparents. During the summer, she discovered she was pregnant. At the time she was interviewed Amina was 12 weeks pregnant but the father of the child, an apprentice at a local car body shop, had disappeared. She had no medical care and was fearful and depressed about what lay ahead. She safely bore a little boy and when last seen, in July 1996, was selling oranges at a road junction with the baby on her back. Amina is no exception to the general rule that teenage mothers tend to have dropped out before becoming pregnant.

Contributor(s): David Stephens

Further information:
David Stephens
Centre for International Education
Institute of Education
University of Sussex
Brighton BN1 9RG
UK

Tel: +44 (0)1273 678712
Fax: +44 (0)1273 678568
Email: d.g.stephens@sussex.ac.uk
Institute of Education, University of Sussex

FREE Information Delivery services from ID21:
Get updates by email: ID21 news
ID21 is enabled by the UK Government Department for International Development(www.dfid.gov.uk) and hosted by the Institute of Development Studies (www.ids.ac.uk/ids), at the University of Sussex, UK. Charitable Company No. 877338. ID21 is a oneworld.net (www.oneworld.org) partner and a mediachannel affiliate (www.mediachannel.org).

Top of the page

Views expressed in INSIGHTS are not necessarily those of DFID, IDS, id21 or other contributing institutions. Copyright remains with the original authors but (unless stated otherwise) articles may be copied or quoted without restriction, provided id21 and originating author(s) and
institution(s) are acknowledged.

Copyright © 2003 id21. All rights reserved.