Go to the id21 home page

id21 logo

insights

id21 logo

insights health #9

Hitting malaria where it hurts

Buying the best?

To buy or not to buy?

Forgotten people

Seeking treatment for childhood fevers in Tanzania

Mosquito nets challenge tradition in Tanzania

Malaria: the acceptable disease in Tanzania

Kenyan communities fight back against malaria

Useful web links

PDF version

Send us your comments on this issue

id21 Home

id21 Society & Economy

id21 Health

id21 Urban Poverty

id21 Education

About id21

Links

Contact id21

Site map

Seeking treatment for childhood fevers in Tanzania

Community health agents, Kinyak Odette and Foka Francoise, treat a mosquito net with insecticide and unfold it to dry in the sun in Lagdo, Cameroon
Community health agents, Kinyak Odette and Foka Francoise, treat a mosquito net with insecticide and unfold it to dry in the sun in Lagdo, Cameroon (© 2005 Rachel Hoy, Courtesy of Photoshare) (Larger version)

In Tanzania, parents seeking treatment for children with severe, often malaria-related, fever vary in their choice of care. Their choice is influenced by a range of social and cultural factors that need to be better understood if children are to be successfully treated.

In urban and peri-urban areas of Tanzania, many parents believe their children suffer from 'degedege' - a local term for malaria-related childhood febrile (fever) illnesses. Parents and carers would prefer, in the first instance, to take their children to a biomedical facility. However, opening and closing times are not always convenient. Consequently, parents often have no choice but to seek out a traditional healer who can provide treatment and comfort at more convenient hours.

Many parents or carers of children with severe fevers do not necessarily follow one single approach to seeking treatment. Despite shared cultural knowledge concerning the causes of degedege, for example, parents deal with their children's illnesses in a variety of different ways.

It is the less obvious social and cultural dynamics of treatment management in households that influence how people seek health care in a crisis situation. These also interact with structural constraints and circumstances that influence how an illness is managed. Such constraints include:

  • Physical, social and communication barriers at health care facilities, such as poor doctor-to-patient communication.
  • A limited ability to use resources, including biomedical health facilities and social networks, due to poverty and social status.
  • Little or no previous experience with the illness - especially young mothers.
  • Bad timing of the illness, such as when health services are closed during a public holiday.
  • the lack of social support and appropriate advice from members of ones social networks.

If malaria treatment strategies are to be successfully implemented, policymakers need to pay attention to:

  • the subtleties of how poor households make health care decisions
  • how uncertainties of life and every day contingencies influence poor people's health care decisions
  • social change in poor communities, such as when new health care interventions like insecticide treated nets are introduced
  • the politics of communication at public health facilities, such as when social status affects communication between health workers and mothers of sick children
  • issues that go beyond the study of beliefs about the causes and origins of the illness like the politics of health care
  • cultural models about the appropriateness of certain treatment seeking behaviours and practices.

Vinay R. Kamat
Department of Anthropology, University of British Columbia, 2119 - 6303 N.W. Marine Drive, Vancouver, British Columbia, V6T 1Z1, Canada
T +1 604 822 4802
F +1 604 822 6161
kamatvin@interchange.ubc.ca

See also

'"I thought it was only ordinary fever!" Cultural knowledge and the micropolitics of therapy seeking for childhood febrile illness in Tanzania', Social Science & Medicine 62(12), pages 2945-2959, by Vinay R. Kamat, 2006

Fatuma's story
A pragmatic quest for treatment

Fatuma visits a Swahili healer to find treatment for her daughter's incessant crying and sleepless nights
Fatuma visits a Swahili healer to find treatment for her daughter's incessant crying and sleepless nights. Unknown to her, perhaps, these are signs of malaria (© 2001 Vinay Kamat) (Larger version)

Fatuma is a 24 year old single mother of two children. She lives in a village near Dar es Salaam. For two weeks she was preoccupied with Mariam, her nine month old daughter who had a constant fever.

The medical officer at the municipal dispensary diagnosed Mariam's condition as malaria and prescribed an antimalarial which didn't have any effect. Fatuma then bought an antimalarial syrup over the counter from a private pharmacy. She also saw a local healer in connection with another problem - Mariam's incessant crying and sleepless nights. The healer performed a divination and concluded that Mariam's illness was linked to visitation of spirits. To Fatuma's satisfaction he recommended ritual medicine.

Fatuma returned with her daughter to the dispensary the next day. A quick blood test revealed that Mariam's haemoglobin was dangerously low. Treating the situation as an emergency, a nurse gave Mariam an antimalarial injection, advising Fatuma to return with her daughter over the next five days to complete the dosage. The nurse also advised Fatuma to pay more attention to Mariam's nutrition as she had become anaemic.

Fatuma had by this time exhausted nearly all the local resources available. She had sought help from diverse and even contradictory medical traditions - modern biomedicine and a traditional Swahili healer. Yet the different problems are in fact signs of the same illness (in this case, cerebral malaria) from a biomedical point of view requiring a single treatment.

Fatuma returned to the dispensary with Mariam over the next five days to complete the prescribed treatment. However, malaria drug resistance meant the treatment was ineffective. Mariam was taken to a district hospital where she was treated with a more effective antimalarial.

FREE Information Delivery services from id21:

Get updates by email: ID21 news

id21 is enabled by the UK Government Department for International Development and hosted by the Institute of Development Studies, at the University of Sussex, UK. Charitable Company No. 877338. id21 is a oneworld.net partner and a mediachannel affiliate

Right-to-Reply:
Comment on any of the issues raised in this Insights.
Read what others have said.

Top of the page

Views expressed on these pages are not necessarily those of DFID, IDS, id21 or other contributing institutions. Copyright remains with the original authors but (unless stated otherwise) any article may be copied or quoted without restriction, provided both source (id21, insights) and authors are properly acknowledged and informed. Copyright © 2006 id21. All rights reserved.